Urging the Super Committee to "Go Big"
On Wednesday, September 21st CRFB hosted a three-panel discussion made up of lawmakers and budget luminaries urging the Super Committee to “Go Big” and develop a large-scale debt reduction package sufficient to stabilize the debt as a share of the economy. All panelists supported the notion that the minimum amount of savings tasked to the super committee, between $1.2 and $1.5 trillion, is an insufficient target for putting the budget on a sustainable path. A video of the event will soon be available, so check back on our homepage.
Participants included former Federal Reserve Chairman Alan Greenspan, Co-chair of the National Commission on Fiscal Responsibility and Reform Erskine Bowles, Senators Mark Warner and Mike Crapo, former CBO and OMB Director Alice Rivlin, former Senator Pete Domenici, Business Roundtable President John Engler, and former SEIU President Andy Stern. See below for the full list of participants. Additionally, a number of prominent policymakers added their voices to the go big movement in recorded remarks that can be found here.
CRFB President Maya MacGuineas, Steve Bell of the Bipartisan policy Center, and Concord Coalition Executive Director Bob Bixby made opening remarks on behalf of their organizations as co-hosts, setting the tone for the “Go Big”, “Go Long”, and “Go Smart” messages.
Overall there were a number of areas of universal agreement across the three panels:
- Failure is not an option. Congress and the President have really backed themselves up against a wall, and kicking the can further down the road to delay making difficult choices is no longer an option.
- $1.5 trillion is an inadequate savings target; most agreed the minimum goal should be at least $4 trillion, while others argued for a higher minimum of $5-6 trillion (Chairman Greenspan), to even beyond that (David Stockman).
- Everything must be on the table – spending cuts, tax reform (including tax expenditures), and entitlement reform.
- There are a lot of good plans out there with multiple ideas to achieve a $4 trillion goal – the Simpson-Bowles and Domenici-Rivlin plans were frequently cited.
Among the many observations and recommendations from participants, Andy Stern’s surprising admission that he regretted not voting for the Bowles-Simpson Fiscal Commission plan may have been one of the most notable moments.
Another common theme was that lawmakers need to acknowledge that the public in many ways is more supportive of a go big approach than many lawmakers right now, and we need to compare the kinds of changes necessary to put debt on a downward path to what might happen if we experience some kind of bond crisis and loss of confidence. The math is pretty simple – without changes now there’s a pretty steep cliff on the horizon. The Super Committee must implement policies that begin to get deficits and debt under control, while at the same time not harming the fragile economic recovery that is a key to restoring increased prosperity and growth.
Panelists agreed that putting in place a strong, ambitious plan now that is phased in will actually lead to increased growth as the drag on the economy diminishes and markets, foreign governments and domestic consumers regain confidence in the U.S. economy and its prospects. Chairman Greenspan, Pete Domenici, Dave Cote, Erskine Bowles, and many other panelists highlighted this confidence element as one of the most serious threats afflicting the economy today and one of the strongest upsides to putting in a place a credible, ambitious debt reduction plan. However, speakers did recognize that debt reduction will be tough politically and economically this decade, but that the long-term benefits were undeniable. As former OMB Director David Stockman stated, “I’d rather have a tough decade than a tough century.”
There was universal agreement on the need to “go big”, and that there is no time for delay. Panelists argued that circumstances and external forces will eventually force lawmakers’ hand, and the better route is to make some tough choices now that begin a longer-term path to sustainable levels of debt and a return to more manageable annual deficits, and perhaps even eventually a balanced budget.
When: September 21, 2011, 2:00 pm - 5:30 pm
Where: Dirksen Senate Office Building, Room 608
To RSVP, email Kingsley Trotter at firstname.lastname@example.org.
The event will also be live webcast -- check back here for the video stream closer to event time.
Welcome: Maya MacGuineas, President, Committee for a Responsible Federal Budget
Panel 1 -- Going Big: Why the Super Committee Must Exceed Its Mandate
- Erskine Bowles, Co-chair, National Commission on Fiscal Responsibility and Reform
- Senator Mike Crapo (R-ID)
- Dave Cote, CEO, Honeywell International
- Alice Rivlin, Former Director, Congressional Budget Office and Former Director, Office of Management and Budget
Panel 2 -- Public Response and Special Interests: The Politics of Going Big
- John Spratt, Former Chairman, House Budget Committee
- Pete Domenici, Former Chairman, Senate Budget Committee
- Charles Kolb, President, Committee for Economic Development
- Dave McCurdy, President and CEO, American Gas Association
- Bill Novelli, Former CEO, AARP
- Andy Stern, Senior Research Fellow, Georgetown Public Policy Institute
Panel 3 -- Deficits and Growth: The Political and Economic Picture Today and Tomorrow
- Senator Mark Warner (D-VA)
- Governor John Engler, President, Business Roundtable
- Alan Greenspan, Former Chair, Federal Reserve Board
- David Stockman, Former Member of Congress and Former Director, Office of Management and Budget
- Jane Harman, President, CEO, and Director, Woodrow Wilson International Center for Scholars, Smithsonian Institution and Former Member of Congress